Insight
Tight oil needs new metrics
*Please note that this report only includes an Excel data file if this is indicated in "What's included" below
Report summary
As tight oil operators focus on navigating the next few months, holding decades of well inventory simply isn't as important. The higher priority is cash flow. Any new wells must pay back incredibly fast. Screening by these metrics reshuffles the cost stack, and the Permian loses some of its luster. On a straight payback metric at today's prices, core zip codes in the Eagle Ford and Bakken represent some of the most competitive acreage in the Lower 48. More mature tight oil basins won't provide years and years of growth potential but can offer portfolio optionality and a safer retreat while prices remain depressed.
Table of contents
- Executive summary
- Investment doesn't go to zero
- Arguing for payback and P/I ratios
- Benchmarking the best tight oil assets
- Lower price decks
- Any upside?
- Conclusion
Tables and charts
This report includes the following images and tables:
-
The pros and cons of payback period vs profitability indexSub-play benchmarking under flat US$55/bbl and US$2/mcf pricesSub-play benchmarking under flat US$40/bbl and US$2/mcf prices
What's included
This report contains:
Other reports you may be interested in
Insight
Global Upstream Update: September 2026
Key themes: novel resource capture strategies, growth opportunities but with caveats, and tougher expansion challenges reveal themselves.
$1,350
Asset Report
Tyrihans
The Tyrihans development consists of the Tyrihans Nord oil and gas field and Tyrihans Sør gas/condensate field.
$3,720
Asset Report
Montney tight gas unconventional play
A detailed analysis of the Montney tight gas unconventional play.
$2,800
