Inform
Coal plant generators will keenly eye legal challenges to ACE
Report summary
The problems with the Clean Power Plan (CPP) are not present in the Affordable Clean Energy (ACE) rule and it is unlikely to be stayed. However, it will be challenged using multiple approaches. In theory, ACE could provide coal plants some relief from early retirements. But power generators will be influenced more by public opinion, the approach taken by regulators and the risk created by the whipsawing nature of US politics. Operators are unlikely to risk capital pursuing unpopular and hard to permit coal plants. The long-term future of coal plants in the US is unlikely to change with ACE.
Table of contents
-
Likely complaint
- BSER for CO2 emissions from existing power plantsshould include outside the fence measures
-
Possible rebuttal
- Outside-the-fence measures for emissions reductions are beyond what EPA may consider
- The ACE rule makes emissions worse because it is legally arbitrary and capricious
- EPA’s ACE rule is legally supportable and not arbitrary and capricious
- Courts may defer to statute language and Congressional intent to determine EPA authority
- The CPP exceeded the statutory authority of the Clean Air Act and had to be repealed
- Severing ACE and CPP could create logically inconsistent outcomes
- The basis for CPP repeal is separate from ACE and legal action is therefore severable
- EPA was wrong to change the baseline in its regulatory impact analysis
- CPP and ACE are separate actions requiring different baselines
- What if Democrats win political control in 2020?
- How will coal plants be impacted?
Tables and charts
No table or charts specified
What's included
This report contains:
Other reports you may be interested in
04 August 2016
Permanent US ratification of the COP21 agreements not a certainty
Insight
Permanent US ratification of the COP21 agreements not a certainty
President Obama will use executive action to ratify the COP21 agreement but politics and the courts will decide the level of US involvement.
$1,10006 December 2018
Cerro San Pedro gold mine
Asset Report
Cerro San Pedro gold mine
A detailed analysis of the Cerro San Pedro gold mine.
$2,25011 April 2017
China’s power market liberalisation gains more momentum
Inform
China’s power market liberalisation gains more momentum
Latest policy shows progress, but generators could face more headwinds
$700
Trusted by leading organisations
